Payless Liquor Robbery Early January


A Facebook post Nov. 10, 2022, sought four suspects in a liquor store robbery. (Image Provided/Carmel Police Department)

Sully Symmes

Last Friday, January 13th, police received reports of a robbery in progress at Payless Liquors at 14580 River Rd. in Carmel.


After utilizing surveillance footage and releasing information to the public, Carmel Police identified Natesia Davidson, 24; Arionna Davis, 21; Kayla Bradshaw, 31; and a 15-year-old juvenile as suspects in the case, and are suspected to have taken 11 bottles of liquor valued at nearly $875 from Payless Liquors in East Carmel. 

Once identified, Carmel Police Department discovered that they were natives of Indianapolis, IN, just south of the Payless Liquors.


The charges are as follows:

Natesia Davidson

Arionna Davis

Kayla Bradshaw


These adults are facing charges of robbery, organized theft and theft. The 15-year-old juvenile faces the same charges in addition to a felony count of intimidation.


After reviewing court documents, Davidson’s bond was set at $150,000. The court documents state that Davidson’s initial hearing to face formal charges will be Tuesday.


The Carmel Police Department requests that anyone with information on the robbery to contact them at 317-571-2500 or Crime Stoppers of Central Indiana (317-262-8477) and reference CPD case number 20-70453, and thanks the public for it’s assistance in identifying these individuals and providing information, which was cited to help lead this case to being solved. 



Current in Carmel:

Read The Reporter: